X-mod and payroll audits for roofing contractors
How your experience mod is calculated and how to get through a workers' comp audit without a surprise bill.
What an experience mod is
Your experience modification factor, or x-mod, compares your company's workers' comp claims to what's expected for a roofing company your size. It's applied directly to your premium, so it's one of the biggest numbers on your policy.
On a roofing payroll, the difference between a 0.85 and a 1.25 can be tens of thousands of dollars a year on the same crew. General contractors and property managers also look at your mod when deciding who gets to bid, so a high one can cost you work, not just premium.
Who calculates it depends on your state. In California, the WCIRB calculates mods. In Texas, Tennessee and Georgia, NCCI does. You qualify once your business is big enough to produce a minimum amount of premium over the rating period. California adjusts its threshold each September ($11,700 as of September 1, 2026); NCCI states set their own.
How your x-mod is calculated
The math has a lot of moving parts, but the idea is simple: your actual losses compared to your expected losses.
- The rating period is three years, and it's not the most recent one. Your mod uses three policy years of payroll and claims, usually ending about a year before the mod takes effect. A claim from this year typically won't hit your mod until next year's renewal, and then it stays for three years.
- Expected losses come from your payroll. The rating bureau multiplies your payroll in each class code by an expected loss rate for that class. More roofing payroll means more expected losses.
- Actual losses come from your claims. Paid amounts plus open reserves the carrier has set aside for each claim.
- Frequency counts more than severity. Each claim is split into a primary portion and an excess portion. The primary portion counts in full; the excess portion is heavily discounted. That means five $8,000 claims usually hurt your mod more than one $40,000 claim.
Why small claims matter: Many roofers assume a few small injuries won't move the needle. Because of the primary/excess split, a string of small claims is exactly what drives a mod up. In many NCCI states, medical-only claims (no lost time) get a 70% discount in the formula, which is a big reason to get injured workers back on modified duty quickly.
How to bring your x-mod down
- Report claims right away. Late-reported claims cost more. Fast reporting keeps reserves lower and gets workers proper care sooner.
- Have a return-to-work plan. Light-duty work (ground crew, material handling, cleanup) can keep a claim medical-only instead of lost-time.
- Watch your open reserves. Ask the carrier to review reserves on old open claims and close claims that are resolved. Overstated reserves inflate your mod until they come down.
- Check your mod worksheet. Confirm the payroll, class codes and claims are actually yours and correct. Errors happen, and they can be fixed.
- Get payroll in the right class. Underreported payroll lowers expected losses, which makes your claims look worse by comparison.
- Invest in fall protection and training. Falls drive the biggest roofing claims. Fewer claims is the only long-term way to a credit mod.
How workers' comp payroll audits work
When your policy is written, your premium is based on an estimate of next year's payroll. After the policy ends, the carrier audits your books and recalculates the premium on what you actually paid. Some audits are a phone or mail questionnaire; larger accounts usually get an in-person or virtual field audit.
What the auditor looks at
- Payroll registers and quarterly payroll tax filings (941s, and the DE 9/DE 9C in California)
- General ledger, cash disbursements and 1099s
- Certificates of insurance for every subcontractor you paid
- Job descriptions and duties for each employee, to confirm class codes
- Overtime records and, in California, time records that support the 5552/5553 wage split
- Owner and officer status (included or excluded from coverage)
The four things that cause surprise bills
- Payroll grew. A busy season, a storm-chasing crew or raises you didn't report. Every extra payroll dollar is charged at the roofing rate.
- Uninsured subcontractors. If a sub can't show a valid workers' comp certificate for the dates they worked for you, the auditor adds what you paid them to your payroll. Usually the full amount, unless their invoices clearly separate labor and materials.
- Class code changes. Office staff, estimators or salespeople who get on roofs, or whose duties aren't documented, get moved into the roofing code.
- Wage-split failures in California. If you reported roofers in 5553 but can't prove their hours, the auditor moves that payroll to 5552.
Audit prep checklist
- Pull payroll reports for the exact policy period, not the calendar year
- Separate overtime premium on your payroll reports so it can be excluded
- Collect a current certificate from every sub, matching the dates you paid them
- List every 1099 payee and whether they're a sub, a supplier or an independent professional
- Write down each employee's job duties and the class code they belong in
- For California roofers in 5553, have time records showing daily start, stop and total hours
- Ask us to review the audit worksheet before you sign anything
If your payroll is running ahead of your estimate, don't wait for the audit. Ask to update the estimate mid-term so the difference gets spread across your remaining payments. Pay-as-you-go workers' comp, where premium is calculated off each payroll run, can take most of the guesswork out of audits.
If you disagree with an audit, ask for the auditor's worksheet, send your records and a written dispute to the carrier promptly, and keep copies. We can help you work through it.
Run your numbers
Frequently asked questions
How long does a claim stay on my x-mod?
Usually three years. Because the rating period skips the most recent year, a claim typically starts affecting your mod about a year after it happens and stays in the calculation for three mods.
Does a new roofing company have an x-mod?
No. Until you have enough history and premium to qualify, you're rated at 1.00, which is average.
Will I always owe money at audit?
No. If your actual payroll came in lower than your estimate, you can get premium back. Bills happen when payroll grew, subs weren't insured, or employees were moved into higher-rated class codes.
Are 1099 roofers counted at audit?
If they don't carry their own workers' comp and can't show you a certificate, most carriers count what you paid them as your payroll. Collect certificates before you pay.
Is overtime included in audited payroll?
In most states, only the straight-time portion counts. The extra half of time-and-a-half is excluded, but only if your payroll records show it separately.
Can I lower my x-mod quickly?
The fastest wins are fixing errors on your mod worksheet and getting the carrier to reduce or close reserves on resolved claims. After that, it comes down to fewer claims over time.
Get ahead of your next audit
We review roofing contractors' mods, class codes and sub certificates before renewal so the numbers hold up. Licensed in CA, TX, TN and GA.
Get a quote Call 951-447-5419